The rapid advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AI) presents a fascinating paradox for education. On one hand, AI tools offer incredible potential to personalise learning, automate tasks, and provide access to vast amounts of information. On the other, a growing concern lingers: are we inadvertently fostering a generation that relies too heavily on AI, potentially at the expense of their own creative and critical thinking abilities? The fear is not unfounded. 

Research is beginning to suggest a correlation between frequent AI use and a decline in critical thinking skills, potentially mediated by increased cognitive offloading – the tendency to delegate cognitive tasks to external aids (Gerlich, 2025). Younger users, particularly those in the 17-25 age bracket, have shown higher dependence on AI tools and correspondingly lower critical thinking scores (Gerlich, 2025). This raises crucial questions for educators: how do we harness the power of AI without diminishing the very skills that empower independent thought, innovation, and effective problem-solving? 

The Danger of Outsourcing Our Minds 

Critical thinking, at its core, involves the ability to analyse, evaluate, and synthesise information to form reasoned judgments (European Research Studies Journal, n.d.). Creativity, meanwhile, is the capacity to generate novel and valuable ideas, to think outside the box and approach challenges with originality (Torrens University Australia, 2018). Both skills are not merely academic pursuits; they are fundamental life skills, essential for navigating a complex world, succeeding in future careers, and contributing meaningfully to society (TeacherToolkit, 2025). Over-reliance on AI can subtly erode these abilities. 

When AI provides instant answers, generates essays, or brainstorms ideas, it can reduce the need for students to engage in the effortful cognitive processes that build these skills (Redwood Bark, 2025). As Sabrina Habib, Associate Professor at the University of South Carolina, notes, students using AI for brainstorming reported a "fixation of the mind," struggling to generate their own ideas after seeing AI suggestions (Redwood Bark, 2025). This dependence can lead to a decline in cognitive resilience – the ability to solve problems independently – and a weakening of the very foundations of creative and critical thought. 

Cultivating Creative and Critical Thinkers Across the Curriculum 

The solution isn't to ban AI from the classroom entirely. Instead, educators must proactively cultivate creative and critical thinking skills across all subject areas, ensuring students learn to engage critically with AI as a tool, rather than passively relying on it as a crutch. Here are some strategies to embed these vital skills: 

1. Foster a Culture of Inquiry and Questioning:  

  • Encourage      "Why?": Promote a classroom environment where students feel      safe to ask questions, challenge assumptions, and explore different      perspectives (CER Education, 2024).
  • Open-Ended      Questions: Regularly pose questions that require more than a simple      factual recall, prompting students to analyse, evaluate, and synthesise      information (Walden University, n.d.). For example, instead of "What      happened in the story?", ask "What were the protagonist's      motivations, and how did they influence the outcome?"

2. Embrace Problem-Based and Project-Based Learning:  

  • Real-World      Challenges: Present students with authentic problems and projects that      require them to apply their knowledge creatively and critically to develop      solutions (CER Education, 2024).
  • Student      Choice: Offer students some autonomy in choosing their project topics      and approaches, fostering ownership and engagement (SplashLearn, n.d.).

3. Explicitly Teach Critical Thinking Skills:  

  • Information      Evaluation: Equip students with the skills to evaluate sources,      identify bias, and determine the credibility of information, especially in      the age of AI-generated content (Edutopia, 2023).
  • Logical      Reasoning: Teach students about different types of reasoning      (deductive, inductive) and common fallacies in arguments (Edutopia, 2023).
  • Metacognitive      Reflection: Encourage students to reflect on their own thinking      processes, identify their strengths and weaknesses, and consider      alternative approaches to problem-solving (Edutopia, 2023).

4. Nurture Creativity Through Exploration and Experimentation:  

  • Embrace      "Messy" Learning: Create a classroom where experimentation      and making mistakes are seen as part of the learning process (The Creation      Station, 2022).
  • Integrate      the Arts: Incorporate visual arts, music, drama, and dance across the      curriculum to foster imaginative thinking and alternative forms of      expression (SplashLearn, n.d.).
  • Provide      Open-Ended Tasks: Offer assignments that allow for multiple solutions      and encourage students to think outside conventional boundaries (Torrens      University Australia, 2018).

5. Facilitate Discussion and Debate:  

  • Diverse      Perspectives: Encourage students to consider different viewpoints on      issues, fostering empathy and a deeper understanding of complexity      (Edutopia, 2023).
  • Respectful      Dialogue: Teach students how to engage in respectful and constructive      debates, supporting their arguments with evidence and reasoning (Graduate      Programs for Educators, n.d.).

6. Integrate AI Mindfully and Critically:  

  • Teach      AI Literacy: Help students understand how AI tools work, their      limitations, and potential biases in their training data (TeacherToolkit,      2025).
  • "Human      First, AI Second": Encourage students to attempt problem-solving      and idea generation independently before using AI as a verification or      supplementary tool (TeacherToolkit, 2025).
  • Critique      AI Output: Teach students to question and evaluate AI-generated      content, prompting them to ask: "Is this accurate? What biases might      be present? How could this be improved?" (TeacherToolkit, 2025).

Conclusion: AI is undoubtedly a powerful tool that will continue to shape our world. However, its integration into education must be approached with careful consideration of its potential impact on fundamental cognitive skills. By consciously fostering creativity and critical thinking across all subjects, we can empower our Year 6 students – and all primary learners – to become not just users of AI, but thoughtful, innovative, and independent thinkers who can navigate the complexities of the 21st century with confidence and ingenuity. The key lies in creating a classroom culture that values questioning, exploration, and the unique power of the human mind.   

Sources: